A
case of mistaken Alfdentity...
Most people even
remotely familiar with film history or popular culture know what Alfalfa
looked like during his Little Rascals career. Not nearly as many people
have seen Alfalfa as an adult (until now, we hope).
This is probably to blame for the fact that any adult male whose hair
is parted in the middle, or who even has dark hair, or looks like
they were born in the first half of the twentieth century, is liable
to be identified as "Alfalfa, from the Our Gang comedies".
This is demonstrated by the following two examples of photographs
that have been put up for auction recently on a major online auction
site.
The below photograph, offered for a starting price of $499, was described
as "a rare vintage 4-1/2 x 7 inch photograph of Carl 'Alfalfa'
Switzer from Our Gang/Little Rascals. [It] shows Alfalfa side profile.
Extremely rare photograph. Signature in fantastic shape. Handwriting
by Alfalfa on the back of photo as well."
  
Above:
Photograph purportedly of an adult Alfalfa. Reverse of photo (right)
is supposed to be further documentation that the image is a grownup
Alfalfa.
The individual shown resembles a young Bob Hope, were it not for
the nose.
Click on left-hand image to enlarge further. The reverse of the
photo says:
Edwin Whubr [?] 1845 Camino Real/Hermosa Beach, Calif/Hal Roach
Prod.
of Our Gang Comedies/Hollywood Calif."
The next picture (below) offered for bid was described as follows:
"This small fortune card is of an obviously older Alfalfa. The
name is Don Barclay and he worked through Hal Roach Studios. The back
says...the weight and date and a pencilled in year of 1936. The fortune
reads 'Though many troubles have beset your path, you have been true
to your friends'..."
It is puzzling exactly how the seller of this photo could have thought
this was Alfalfa, unless it was assumed that Alfalfa's real name was
"Don Barclay", and that, in 1936, Alfalfa was "older"
(he was 9 years old in 1936, the date on the back of the card.) The
Alfalfa-like hairdo probably nullified all these factors. The inscription
in the back fits the fictional Alfalfa legend of tragedy, etc. etc.,
but unfortunately this picture is definitely not Alfalfa.
In fact, Don Barclay was an actor who appeared in two Little Rascals
episodes during the Wally Albright era, most notably playing the prissy
chauffeur in "Honky Donkey" (at least it was another Hal
Roach/Little Rascals performer!)
"Photo
booth" images of "Alfalfa" offered for bid on online
auction site:
This
series of photos was recently offered at on online auction site.
The product was entitled "1930s Snapshots of Alfalfa, Our Gang
Comedies", and the auction description included the text, "This
listing presents one series of four circa 1930's photo booth like
sepia tone snapshot images of Carl Switzer (8/7/27 - 1/21/59), also
known as "Alfalfa" from Our Gang Comedies or The Little
Rascals." We have no idea who this boy really is, and we readily
admit that he seems to possess charismatic looks that might have
led to a show business career. But whoever this young man is, he
is definitely and obviously not Alfalfa.

Above:
Entire snapshot strip as offered for auction.
Below: Details of the four "Alfalfa" images.

We have no doubt that further examples of Alfalfa misidentification
will turn up in the months ahead, and we will of course include
them on this page.
Back to top
Back
to "Alfalfa Nation" main
|